{
  "schema_version": "1.0.0",
  "verification_stage_contract": "bounded-workflow-v2",
  "entity_id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
  "points": [
    {
      "id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "score": 5.2,
      "popularity": 0.0,
      "stars": 4116,
      "momentum": 7.5,
      "score_components": {
        "usefulness": 5.2,
        "novelty": 4.0,
        "momentum": 3.5,
        "maturity": 4.0,
        "open_source_build_quality": 8.4,
        "evidence": 7.2,
        "commercial_workflow_potential": 5.6,
        "setup_ease": 5.0
      },
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "pricing_fingerprint": null,
      "pricing_summary": null,
      "pricing_facts": [],
      "pricing_checked_at": null,
      "pricing_stale": null,
      "version": "v2.5.0-ce",
      "last_release_at": "2026-09-16T01:30:06Z",
      "last_release_url": "https://github.com/OpenCSGs/csghub/releases/tag/v2.5.0-ce",
      "maintenance_status": "active",
      "integration_fingerprint": "ca4a3980b2791c51",
      "integration_count": 1,
      "integrations": [
        "Hugging Face"
      ],
      "source_observed_at": "2026-09-28T13:47:34.707135Z",
      "observation_source_url": "https://api.github.com/graphql",
      "observation_extractor_version": "github-observer-v2",
      "observation_refs": {
        "stars": "obs_b0d3e4cf50598d89ade2164c",
        "version": "obs_0f398760c112490f393d6707",
        "last_release_at": "obs_ca9710df939e51cd43a9dd22",
        "last_release_url": "obs_331fa69abb0be56fddca6f6d",
        "pushed_at": "obs_b73a639062f575b864e0c441",
        "archived": "obs_88ed1b332b4312387bd6e88f",
        "default_branch": "obs_34a70ab97a70238833886bed",
        "default_branch_updated_at": "obs_64116e4cce9e1801ed5150a0",
        "maintenance_status": "obs_a1550434c09e81a13b29328c",
        "momentum": "obs_3c89b2ea3c985b99c9389a9c",
        "repository_topics": "obs_fc41fb6fa798479b170bc303",
        "integrations": "obs_ceafde5838501d3b141e1e45",
        "integration_fingerprint": "obs_4fce20f022f702bcff656574",
        "deployment_models": "obs_08253d51f4ba7cc0ae4caf34",
        "extensibility": "obs_5003176881f964cb74e98a8e"
      },
      "observed_fields": [
        "integration_count",
        "integration_fingerprint",
        "integrations",
        "last_release_at",
        "maintenance_status",
        "momentum",
        "popularity",
        "pricing_checked_at",
        "pricing_facts",
        "pricing_fingerprint",
        "pricing_stale",
        "pricing_summary",
        "risk",
        "score",
        "score_components",
        "stars",
        "tier",
        "verdict",
        "verification_stage",
        "version"
      ],
      "date": "2026-09-28"
    },
    {
      "id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "score": 5.2,
      "popularity": 0.0,
      "stars": 4116,
      "momentum": 7.5,
      "score_components": {
        "usefulness": 5.2,
        "novelty": 4.0,
        "momentum": 3.5,
        "maturity": 4.0,
        "open_source_build_quality": 8.4,
        "evidence": 7.2,
        "commercial_workflow_potential": 5.6,
        "setup_ease": 5.0
      },
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "pricing_fingerprint": null,
      "pricing_summary": null,
      "pricing_facts": [],
      "pricing_checked_at": null,
      "pricing_stale": null,
      "version": "v2.5.0-ce",
      "last_release_at": "2026-09-16T01:30:06Z",
      "last_release_url": "https://github.com/OpenCSGs/csghub/releases/tag/v2.5.0-ce",
      "maintenance_status": "active",
      "integration_fingerprint": "ca4a3980b2791c51",
      "integration_count": 1,
      "integrations": [
        "Hugging Face"
      ],
      "source_observed_at": "2026-09-29T17:08:16.498456Z",
      "observation_source_url": "https://api.github.com/graphql",
      "observation_extractor_version": "github-observer-v2",
      "observation_refs": {
        "stars": "obs_95c8d0973c102d89edcd5b3a",
        "version": "obs_d47079563b53e46174f12e40",
        "last_release_at": "obs_0abf792e0a772805836d8dac",
        "last_release_url": "obs_cd7588c93a4d7719f7e86c1d",
        "pushed_at": "obs_2b0fa667a3118d74cbc1ee33",
        "archived": "obs_6ed51902a0f22d0261017f69",
        "default_branch": "obs_e4ca7438ac6fde1c2b8edccd",
        "default_branch_updated_at": "obs_ecb533440d4f13a84c47f5f4",
        "maintenance_status": "obs_8e8c6fdb0e66cbe5c9598799",
        "momentum": "obs_42ac1bc793dbfa860dab5523",
        "repository_topics": "obs_6c41a1b269813abb740211ee",
        "integrations": "obs_49fa3411b5d9d42196fac120",
        "integration_fingerprint": "obs_3001d3658140f9468272f0be",
        "deployment_models": "obs_b10a8f2e89b44fe47a09d77f",
        "extensibility": "obs_10983aba595da0b10e35fc7e"
      },
      "observed_fields": [
        "integration_count",
        "integration_fingerprint",
        "integrations",
        "last_release_at",
        "maintenance_status",
        "momentum",
        "popularity",
        "pricing_checked_at",
        "pricing_facts",
        "pricing_fingerprint",
        "pricing_stale",
        "pricing_summary",
        "risk",
        "score",
        "score_components",
        "stars",
        "tier",
        "verdict",
        "verification_stage",
        "version"
      ],
      "date": "2026-09-29"
    },
    {
      "id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "score": 5.2,
      "popularity": 0.0,
      "stars": 4118,
      "momentum": 7.5,
      "score_components": {
        "usefulness": 5.2,
        "novelty": 4.0,
        "momentum": 3.5,
        "maturity": 4.0,
        "open_source_build_quality": 8.4,
        "evidence": 7.2,
        "commercial_workflow_potential": 5.6,
        "setup_ease": 5.0
      },
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "pricing_fingerprint": null,
      "pricing_summary": null,
      "pricing_facts": [],
      "pricing_checked_at": null,
      "pricing_stale": null,
      "version": "v2.5.0-ce",
      "last_release_at": "2026-09-16T01:30:06Z",
      "last_release_url": "https://github.com/OpenCSGs/csghub/releases/tag/v2.5.0-ce",
      "maintenance_status": "active",
      "integration_fingerprint": "ca4a3980b2791c51",
      "integration_count": 1,
      "integrations": [
        "Hugging Face"
      ],
      "source_observed_at": "2026-09-30T05:08:12.323055Z",
      "observation_source_url": "https://api.github.com/graphql",
      "observation_extractor_version": "github-observer-v2",
      "observation_refs": {
        "stars": "obs_eb0fdc22690dc6bede696351",
        "version": "obs_3764bde79f15d6a0cacef855",
        "last_release_at": "obs_6d3bce24adfd97d95ffd47a3",
        "last_release_url": "obs_3e80d0186de355a5b47bfc0c",
        "pushed_at": "obs_5261dada680f0078387821ed",
        "archived": "obs_9eea98693eb5f533eecce246",
        "default_branch": "obs_a82575b4433e253ae42e291f",
        "default_branch_updated_at": "obs_81e64115ec504340a782ae16",
        "maintenance_status": "obs_1dd1c9e439bfd22bab1af3ec",
        "momentum": "obs_f5f5cdb9e6302548ad7d4d3c",
        "repository_topics": "obs_e7f1a80f2eb32475c6d73063",
        "integrations": "obs_a62ebf10162044d1b28a6f59",
        "integration_fingerprint": "obs_8c8b309a72b1ad5696d21804",
        "deployment_models": "obs_3fc430888e8168654c9c25e3",
        "extensibility": "obs_0f300abef1a0574e39815ff4"
      },
      "observed_fields": [
        "integration_count",
        "integration_fingerprint",
        "integrations",
        "last_release_at",
        "maintenance_status",
        "momentum",
        "popularity",
        "pricing_checked_at",
        "pricing_facts",
        "pricing_fingerprint",
        "pricing_stale",
        "pricing_summary",
        "risk",
        "score",
        "score_components",
        "stars",
        "tier",
        "verdict",
        "verification_stage",
        "version"
      ],
      "date": "2026-09-30"
    },
    {
      "id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "score": 5.2,
      "popularity": 0.0,
      "stars": 4059,
      "momentum": 7.5,
      "score_components": {
        "usefulness": 5.2,
        "novelty": 4.0,
        "momentum": 3.5,
        "maturity": 4.0,
        "open_source_build_quality": 8.4,
        "evidence": 7.2,
        "commercial_workflow_potential": 5.6,
        "setup_ease": 5.0
      },
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "pricing_fingerprint": null,
      "pricing_summary": null,
      "pricing_facts": [],
      "pricing_checked_at": null,
      "pricing_stale": null,
      "version": "v2.5.0-ce",
      "last_release_at": "2026-09-16T01:30:06Z",
      "last_release_url": "https://github.com/OpenCSGs/csghub/releases/tag/v2.5.0-ce",
      "maintenance_status": "active",
      "integration_fingerprint": "ca4a3980b2791c51",
      "integration_count": 1,
      "integrations": [
        "Hugging Face"
      ],
      "source_observed_at": "2026-10-01T21:24:16.558226Z",
      "observation_source_url": "https://api.github.com/graphql",
      "observation_extractor_version": "github-observer-v2",
      "observation_refs": {
        "stars": "obs_24d242c0e2e192029cdad13d",
        "version": "obs_0a8e7cd8d5ae6b31d7f3804a",
        "last_release_at": "obs_739fdc34b96794c736766907",
        "last_release_url": "obs_ed4413e4fc12aa2769a46a28",
        "pushed_at": "obs_fb2762abf651d9f84fbabd4e",
        "archived": "obs_f449723c04b1148f58a1e3a6",
        "default_branch": "obs_0320b007ed8959b744066eb4",
        "default_branch_updated_at": "obs_492420c4c6705d8e5f4ed3fc",
        "maintenance_status": "obs_7e6d2063431cf2ebecc0d83f",
        "momentum": "obs_fb4f860e9c8051ecf1d505d6",
        "repository_topics": "obs_02f68f5397f864c37ead726e",
        "integrations": "obs_ce800f7aa62a1799437ae985",
        "integration_fingerprint": "obs_4a4fdfea6b7ea8258d282db4",
        "deployment_models": "obs_510c731ac6d097736ba52219",
        "extensibility": "obs_1a0159e907a464a7cc5cc850"
      },
      "observed_fields": [
        "integration_count",
        "integration_fingerprint",
        "integrations",
        "last_release_at",
        "maintenance_status",
        "momentum",
        "popularity",
        "pricing_checked_at",
        "pricing_facts",
        "pricing_fingerprint",
        "pricing_stale",
        "pricing_summary",
        "risk",
        "score",
        "score_components",
        "stars",
        "tier",
        "verdict",
        "verification_stage",
        "version"
      ],
      "date": "2026-10-01"
    },
    {
      "id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "score": 5.2,
      "popularity": 0.0,
      "stars": 4059,
      "momentum": 7.5,
      "score_components": {
        "usefulness": 5.2,
        "novelty": 4.0,
        "momentum": 3.5,
        "maturity": 4.0,
        "open_source_build_quality": 8.4,
        "evidence": 7.2,
        "commercial_workflow_potential": 5.6,
        "setup_ease": 5.0
      },
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "pricing_fingerprint": null,
      "pricing_summary": null,
      "pricing_facts": [],
      "pricing_checked_at": null,
      "pricing_stale": null,
      "version": "v2.5.0-ce",
      "last_release_at": "2026-09-16T01:30:06Z",
      "last_release_url": "https://github.com/OpenCSGs/csghub/releases/tag/v2.5.0-ce",
      "maintenance_status": "active",
      "integration_fingerprint": "ca4a3980b2791c51",
      "integration_count": 1,
      "integrations": [
        "Hugging Face"
      ],
      "source_observed_at": "2026-10-02T17:11:36.588066Z",
      "observation_source_url": "https://api.github.com/graphql",
      "observation_extractor_version": "github-observer-v2",
      "observation_refs": {
        "stars": "obs_3af494f656756b9f8cc0c92a",
        "version": "obs_b330b8c860dc38812e87b5e0",
        "last_release_at": "obs_939ff326323cddf0a6d5dd49",
        "last_release_url": "obs_15874c40e19f965bc116ab03",
        "pushed_at": "obs_081a5c0b064ab92ec1c886bd",
        "archived": "obs_397b98c3ceaa3b50267b38ee",
        "default_branch": "obs_46f2415bd1d34f1a57d1454b",
        "default_branch_updated_at": "obs_acb17999d5b5315d58a3a317",
        "maintenance_status": "obs_e34b50d581028e3b714f3181",
        "momentum": "obs_57e6ba15ad5b5673526ad576",
        "repository_topics": "obs_ee921ad5c72d9449b5de9663",
        "integrations": "obs_e37035f2c6dec61a8306fc18",
        "integration_fingerprint": "obs_9831df6fa0bcf7a774d3d9ae",
        "deployment_models": "obs_f96b6c57f5b7e5ed6156134e",
        "extensibility": "obs_f4cd1b1173ce300aa2bc7f58"
      },
      "observed_fields": [
        "integration_count",
        "integration_fingerprint",
        "integrations",
        "last_release_at",
        "maintenance_status",
        "momentum",
        "popularity",
        "pricing_checked_at",
        "pricing_facts",
        "pricing_fingerprint",
        "pricing_stale",
        "pricing_summary",
        "risk",
        "score",
        "score_components",
        "stars",
        "tier",
        "verdict",
        "verification_stage",
        "version"
      ],
      "date": "2026-10-02"
    },
    {
      "id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "score": 5.2,
      "popularity": 0.0,
      "stars": 4059,
      "momentum": 7.5,
      "score_components": {
        "usefulness": 5.2,
        "novelty": 4.0,
        "momentum": 3.5,
        "maturity": 4.0,
        "open_source_build_quality": 8.4,
        "evidence": 7.2,
        "commercial_workflow_potential": 5.6,
        "setup_ease": 5.0
      },
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "pricing_fingerprint": null,
      "pricing_summary": null,
      "pricing_facts": [],
      "pricing_checked_at": null,
      "pricing_stale": null,
      "version": "v2.5.0-ce",
      "last_release_at": "2026-09-16T01:30:06Z",
      "last_release_url": "https://github.com/OpenCSGs/csghub/releases/tag/v2.5.0-ce",
      "maintenance_status": "active",
      "integration_fingerprint": "ca4a3980b2791c51",
      "integration_count": 1,
      "integrations": [
        "Hugging Face"
      ],
      "source_observed_at": "2026-10-03T17:13:14.190776Z",
      "observation_source_url": "https://api.github.com/graphql",
      "observation_extractor_version": "github-observer-v2",
      "observation_refs": {
        "stars": "obs_381ca095db1e0b8f0e0a2dd4",
        "version": "obs_101d4a1fc4b6a5a9aa5be21a",
        "last_release_at": "obs_8fdeb256258a2b28d791f713",
        "last_release_url": "obs_2341b09b5ea9dc305cf1bba2",
        "pushed_at": "obs_a46bfc97f1c94724682213a6",
        "archived": "obs_911d24a1a4a03a952a52e38f",
        "default_branch": "obs_d2685b987df9fb292f95812b",
        "default_branch_updated_at": "obs_40d3f3ace8c86d0a9161ce71",
        "maintenance_status": "obs_228e1fcc94c7f0b87fcd94e9",
        "momentum": "obs_d8d0b9488599e49e2251310f",
        "repository_topics": "obs_034578eb7d9d7c9f476fae78",
        "integrations": "obs_cfd5418e9c8fd5fbd5d1d324",
        "integration_fingerprint": "obs_3c15ba2b7a1ac34795f09d75",
        "deployment_models": "obs_b7811f54af50173999b96c89",
        "extensibility": "obs_a97f01f9cb237c222b36d767"
      },
      "observed_fields": [
        "integration_count",
        "integration_fingerprint",
        "integrations",
        "last_release_at",
        "maintenance_status",
        "momentum",
        "popularity",
        "pricing_checked_at",
        "pricing_facts",
        "pricing_fingerprint",
        "pricing_stale",
        "pricing_summary",
        "risk",
        "score",
        "score_components",
        "stars",
        "tier",
        "verdict",
        "verification_stage",
        "version"
      ],
      "date": "2026-10-03"
    },
    {
      "id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "score": 5.2,
      "popularity": 0.0,
      "stars": 4057,
      "momentum": 7.0,
      "score_components": {
        "usefulness": 5.2,
        "novelty": 4.0,
        "momentum": 3.5,
        "maturity": 4.0,
        "open_source_build_quality": 8.4,
        "evidence": 7.2,
        "commercial_workflow_potential": 5.6,
        "setup_ease": 5.0
      },
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "pricing_fingerprint": null,
      "pricing_summary": null,
      "pricing_facts": [],
      "pricing_checked_at": null,
      "pricing_stale": null,
      "version": "v2.5.0-ce",
      "last_release_at": "2026-09-16T01:30:06Z",
      "last_release_url": "https://github.com/OpenCSGs/csghub/releases/tag/v2.5.0-ce",
      "maintenance_status": "active",
      "integration_fingerprint": "ca4a3980b2791c51",
      "integration_count": 1,
      "integrations": [
        "Hugging Face"
      ],
      "source_observed_at": "2026-10-05T17:12:19.837870Z",
      "observation_source_url": "https://api.github.com/graphql",
      "observation_extractor_version": "github-observer-v2",
      "observation_refs": {
        "stars": "obs_f1641d52cc0d56eb311fcce0",
        "version": "obs_61005126981421c355aff695",
        "last_release_at": "obs_92b76fb1325beb23e5c2baea",
        "last_release_url": "obs_a0fbbbfeceed3900ff5d2491",
        "pushed_at": "obs_0c889c27c7b2a5eddcf34695",
        "archived": "obs_5dcb373624d11ba90776f25c",
        "default_branch": "obs_90f952e8196c80fef5364c7c",
        "default_branch_updated_at": "obs_bc96f9a993df8deaf7632895",
        "maintenance_status": "obs_59112b236188771699b91699",
        "momentum": "obs_3811c75d3fff0a32a8f9ad40",
        "repository_topics": "obs_d1d1d233625cf415a0af420c",
        "integrations": "obs_5e65ae567488d22a5bb42080",
        "integration_fingerprint": "obs_c11037394aa0110d1092f721",
        "deployment_models": "obs_8f735a263298bbc7e4f28f76",
        "extensibility": "obs_0ee469995eea94dc2c5fe049"
      },
      "observed_fields": [
        "integration_count",
        "integration_fingerprint",
        "integrations",
        "last_release_at",
        "maintenance_status",
        "momentum",
        "popularity",
        "pricing_checked_at",
        "pricing_facts",
        "pricing_fingerprint",
        "pricing_stale",
        "pricing_summary",
        "risk",
        "score",
        "score_components",
        "stars",
        "tier",
        "verdict",
        "verification_stage",
        "version"
      ],
      "date": "2026-10-05"
    },
    {
      "id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "score": 5.2,
      "popularity": 0.0,
      "stars": 4059,
      "momentum": 7.5,
      "score_components": {
        "usefulness": 5.2,
        "novelty": 4.0,
        "momentum": 3.5,
        "maturity": 4.0,
        "open_source_build_quality": 8.4,
        "evidence": 7.2,
        "commercial_workflow_potential": 5.6,
        "setup_ease": 5.0
      },
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "pricing_fingerprint": null,
      "pricing_summary": null,
      "pricing_facts": [],
      "pricing_checked_at": null,
      "pricing_stale": null,
      "version": "v2.5.0-ce",
      "last_release_at": "2026-09-16T01:30:06Z",
      "last_release_url": "https://github.com/OpenCSGs/csghub/releases/tag/v2.5.0-ce",
      "maintenance_status": "active",
      "integration_fingerprint": "ca4a3980b2791c51",
      "integration_count": 1,
      "integrations": [
        "Hugging Face"
      ],
      "source_observed_at": "2026-10-06T17:10:49.497470Z",
      "observation_source_url": "https://api.github.com/graphql",
      "observation_extractor_version": "github-observer-v2",
      "observation_refs": {
        "stars": "obs_0dbfdcb151b7fee2fbf694ee",
        "version": "obs_faba3e1ed6e9c823192409a4",
        "last_release_at": "obs_284c2fcda2c87e82ae525b25",
        "last_release_url": "obs_36ff7728a470c9be74807aa7",
        "pushed_at": "obs_c232dab225e608631c857a77",
        "archived": "obs_02ad6ea30d92c7c5f58055c7",
        "default_branch": "obs_64fba3f95a34f722cc8c5109",
        "default_branch_updated_at": "obs_418975c381b7678bbe83959c",
        "maintenance_status": "obs_f245518519b139744a2f5bf5",
        "momentum": "obs_82a77606429749f0c6d6386e",
        "repository_topics": "obs_3fd55f461c3deb787fc327be",
        "integrations": "obs_f0aa74a1fbf913b9891d72ae",
        "integration_fingerprint": "obs_355fa4a27944f38308494601",
        "deployment_models": "obs_19c35d96a891b2e616005613",
        "extensibility": "obs_bc50c5d518303afb53188735"
      },
      "observed_fields": [
        "integration_count",
        "integration_fingerprint",
        "integrations",
        "last_release_at",
        "maintenance_status",
        "momentum",
        "popularity",
        "pricing_checked_at",
        "pricing_facts",
        "pricing_fingerprint",
        "pricing_stale",
        "pricing_summary",
        "risk",
        "score",
        "score_components",
        "stars",
        "tier",
        "verdict",
        "verification_stage",
        "version"
      ],
      "date": "2026-10-06"
    },
    {
      "id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "score": 5.2,
      "popularity": 0.0,
      "stars": 4059,
      "momentum": 7.5,
      "score_components": {
        "usefulness": 5.2,
        "novelty": 4.0,
        "momentum": 3.5,
        "maturity": 4.0,
        "open_source_build_quality": 8.4,
        "evidence": 7.2,
        "commercial_workflow_potential": 5.6,
        "setup_ease": 5.0
      },
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "pricing_fingerprint": null,
      "pricing_summary": null,
      "pricing_facts": [],
      "pricing_checked_at": null,
      "pricing_stale": null,
      "version": "v2.5.0-ce",
      "last_release_at": "2026-09-16T01:30:06Z",
      "last_release_url": "https://github.com/OpenCSGs/csghub/releases/tag/v2.5.0-ce",
      "maintenance_status": "active",
      "integration_fingerprint": "ca4a3980b2791c51",
      "integration_count": 1,
      "integrations": [
        "Hugging Face"
      ],
      "source_observed_at": "2026-10-07T17:10:55.089768Z",
      "observation_source_url": "https://api.github.com/graphql",
      "observation_extractor_version": "github-observer-v2",
      "observation_refs": {
        "stars": "obs_07bf62c07a13dc8fce7c6002",
        "version": "obs_22f614196335d835abc06e62",
        "last_release_at": "obs_bbca95dd592098c363a44957",
        "last_release_url": "obs_96b5f3d1858ba2392c103fb1",
        "pushed_at": "obs_0a238f9e58f9f3edf4cc98fe",
        "archived": "obs_fc914bb7d55e7629bb8d53ef",
        "default_branch": "obs_cd79bb0512deb521f8f5094b",
        "default_branch_updated_at": "obs_dd5c0692604c9cc5fad210bf",
        "maintenance_status": "obs_773a99fbd2cd28ec63e677d8",
        "momentum": "obs_b9cfcd7cf085955f5fe355e6",
        "repository_topics": "obs_03cb76065af2953c4456d23b",
        "integrations": "obs_96991eea4370260d8c0cb8dd",
        "integration_fingerprint": "obs_2083f66fa11b2a8653dddeb8",
        "deployment_models": "obs_5f9550bd1942d9e9320ca088",
        "extensibility": "obs_2263727f8b455cc819980ff2"
      },
      "observed_fields": [
        "integration_count",
        "integration_fingerprint",
        "integrations",
        "last_release_at",
        "maintenance_status",
        "momentum",
        "popularity",
        "pricing_checked_at",
        "pricing_facts",
        "pricing_fingerprint",
        "pricing_stale",
        "pricing_summary",
        "risk",
        "score",
        "score_components",
        "stars",
        "tier",
        "verdict",
        "verification_stage",
        "version"
      ],
      "date": "2026-10-07"
    },
    {
      "id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "score": 5.2,
      "popularity": 0.0,
      "stars": 4060,
      "momentum": 7.8,
      "score_components": {
        "usefulness": 5.2,
        "novelty": 4.0,
        "momentum": 3.5,
        "maturity": 4.0,
        "open_source_build_quality": 8.4,
        "evidence": 7.2,
        "commercial_workflow_potential": 5.6,
        "setup_ease": 5.0
      },
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "pricing_fingerprint": null,
      "pricing_summary": null,
      "pricing_facts": [],
      "pricing_checked_at": null,
      "pricing_stale": null,
      "version": "v2.5.0-ce",
      "last_release_at": "2026-09-16T01:30:06Z",
      "last_release_url": "https://github.com/OpenCSGs/csghub/releases/tag/v2.5.0-ce",
      "maintenance_status": "active",
      "integration_fingerprint": "ca4a3980b2791c51",
      "integration_count": 1,
      "integrations": [
        "Hugging Face"
      ],
      "source_observed_at": "2026-10-08T05:15:53.503430Z",
      "observation_source_url": "https://api.github.com/graphql",
      "observation_extractor_version": "github-observer-v2",
      "observation_refs": {
        "stars": "obs_5e91e9456cc757980717dc18",
        "version": "obs_714701b07fb2c8f82d88386e",
        "last_release_at": "obs_a03d1605cfc02f4d07ba7c6d",
        "last_release_url": "obs_3d55e70595f483ed5fd5ec15",
        "pushed_at": "obs_8ab3bf732add9cc5606e95dd",
        "archived": "obs_03a09da0a10feb2867e0fc0a",
        "default_branch": "obs_5cf5fd5e6f0851b4b38b739c",
        "default_branch_updated_at": "obs_ccbf485f4015551aa8bd5f08",
        "maintenance_status": "obs_e96b441bceccbceb9684d584",
        "momentum": "obs_291c23e0e392a1db9c96fd4c",
        "repository_topics": "obs_eb63285c67b0289ef8f7f8a9",
        "integrations": "obs_32e218c9878c9dbe2d37723c",
        "integration_fingerprint": "obs_3a22afea2c244f57ec307335",
        "deployment_models": "obs_5f25aaf418edcaaecc64c8cc",
        "extensibility": "obs_1f529587dfebcea3a6fb2811"
      },
      "observed_fields": [
        "integration_count",
        "integration_fingerprint",
        "integrations",
        "last_release_at",
        "maintenance_status",
        "momentum",
        "popularity",
        "pricing_checked_at",
        "pricing_facts",
        "pricing_fingerprint",
        "pricing_stale",
        "pricing_summary",
        "risk",
        "score",
        "score_components",
        "stars",
        "tier",
        "verdict",
        "verification_stage",
        "version"
      ],
      "date": "2026-10-08"
    },
    {
      "id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "score": 5.2,
      "popularity": 0.0,
      "stars": 4058,
      "momentum": 7.5,
      "score_components": {
        "usefulness": 5.2,
        "novelty": 4.0,
        "momentum": 3.5,
        "maturity": 4.0,
        "open_source_build_quality": 8.4,
        "evidence": 7.2,
        "commercial_workflow_potential": 5.6,
        "setup_ease": 5.0
      },
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "pricing_fingerprint": null,
      "pricing_summary": null,
      "pricing_facts": [],
      "pricing_checked_at": null,
      "pricing_stale": null,
      "version": "v2.5.0-ce",
      "last_release_at": "2026-09-16T01:30:06Z",
      "last_release_url": "https://github.com/OpenCSGs/csghub/releases/tag/v2.5.0-ce",
      "maintenance_status": "active",
      "integration_fingerprint": "ca4a3980b2791c51",
      "integration_count": 1,
      "integrations": [
        "Hugging Face"
      ],
      "source_observed_at": "2026-10-09T17:10:43.538271Z",
      "observation_source_url": "https://api.github.com/graphql",
      "observation_extractor_version": "github-observer-v2",
      "observation_refs": {
        "stars": "obs_63dd3361c41e97aec23a3643",
        "version": "obs_810996645ba69be060b8f437",
        "last_release_at": "obs_bd74db09d6ecefc57a4ee92f",
        "last_release_url": "obs_e46b767b22bcd58a4b87a5b1",
        "pushed_at": "obs_7352171fbda67679d9cc3aa3",
        "archived": "obs_a60f11213e8d7d7bd9384647",
        "default_branch": "obs_bfe3642083459103021a932e",
        "default_branch_updated_at": "obs_fc7a9f015d1591a5085b47dd",
        "maintenance_status": "obs_6fa717ee549e602db90f1d61",
        "momentum": "obs_c9977db2f3c6355ed1094450",
        "repository_topics": "obs_7c95d880dc846a6bcf1705b6",
        "integrations": "obs_390f0dff866dfcc443e283cd",
        "integration_fingerprint": "obs_bd91b7470a1d87ae0445ece3",
        "deployment_models": "obs_486bebba48255b0562ed3b76",
        "extensibility": "obs_184605e15465b9c91b0654d7"
      },
      "observed_fields": [
        "integration_count",
        "integration_fingerprint",
        "integrations",
        "last_release_at",
        "maintenance_status",
        "momentum",
        "popularity",
        "pricing_checked_at",
        "pricing_facts",
        "pricing_fingerprint",
        "pricing_stale",
        "pricing_summary",
        "risk",
        "score",
        "score_components",
        "stars",
        "tier",
        "verdict",
        "verification_stage",
        "version"
      ],
      "date": "2026-10-09"
    },
    {
      "id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "score": 5.2,
      "popularity": 0.0,
      "stars": 4058,
      "momentum": 7.5,
      "score_components": {
        "usefulness": 5.2,
        "novelty": 4.0,
        "momentum": 3.5,
        "maturity": 4.0,
        "open_source_build_quality": 8.4,
        "evidence": 7.2,
        "commercial_workflow_potential": 5.6,
        "setup_ease": 5.0
      },
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "pricing_fingerprint": null,
      "pricing_summary": null,
      "pricing_facts": [],
      "pricing_checked_at": null,
      "pricing_stale": null,
      "version": "v2.5.0-ce",
      "last_release_at": "2026-09-16T01:30:06Z",
      "last_release_url": "https://github.com/OpenCSGs/csghub/releases/tag/v2.5.0-ce",
      "maintenance_status": "active",
      "integration_fingerprint": "ca4a3980b2791c51",
      "integration_count": 1,
      "integrations": [
        "Hugging Face"
      ],
      "source_observed_at": "2026-10-10T17:09:29.745535Z",
      "observation_source_url": "https://api.github.com/graphql",
      "observation_extractor_version": "github-observer-v2",
      "observation_refs": {
        "stars": "obs_bf5739066d0d11f050611c05",
        "version": "obs_9b6758be9ce6faa1e081c204",
        "last_release_at": "obs_478520d7803d0ab6dc35d324",
        "last_release_url": "obs_b490a60cca7c2f12dd33471e",
        "pushed_at": "obs_360df9fc02175a4e22daf2bd",
        "archived": "obs_d82d61cc88bdbc1443b3fb7a",
        "default_branch": "obs_a79e28fbba9ad90d86fefb9c",
        "default_branch_updated_at": "obs_cb8df3b03b2a53d553a0c089",
        "maintenance_status": "obs_2ae83468b26206427bf67f3e",
        "momentum": "obs_1afb9286fbcec37be556dd75",
        "repository_topics": "obs_e441fa6a6482a0aa761a2d18",
        "integrations": "obs_90c0f42c3dfab9f3e1530bc6",
        "integration_fingerprint": "obs_a16e1338b81466963842955e",
        "deployment_models": "obs_4067af60e420bddf7557ec15",
        "extensibility": "obs_e3cb67562a5950b26bf5dcee"
      },
      "observed_fields": [
        "integration_count",
        "integration_fingerprint",
        "integrations",
        "last_release_at",
        "maintenance_status",
        "momentum",
        "popularity",
        "pricing_checked_at",
        "pricing_facts",
        "pricing_fingerprint",
        "pricing_stale",
        "pricing_summary",
        "risk",
        "score",
        "score_components",
        "stars",
        "tier",
        "verdict",
        "verification_stage",
        "version"
      ],
      "date": "2026-10-10"
    }
  ],
  "changes": [
    {
      "id": "evt_784cb2f020f705c53437",
      "entity_id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "item_url": "/item/opencsgs-csghub/",
      "title": "opencsgs/csghub",
      "category": "other",
      "kind": "stars_changed",
      "occurred_at": "2026-10-09T17:10:43.538271Z",
      "before": 4059,
      "after": 4058,
      "explanation": "Stars changed: 4059 → 4058.",
      "explanation_scope": "catalog_snapshot_delta",
      "evidence_refs": {},
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "score": 5.2,
      "entity_kind": "open_source",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "type": "Dataset",
      "section": "Research",
      "local_ai": false,
      "local_model_compatible": false,
      "discovery_topic": "research",
      "discovery_topic_status": "unreviewed",
      "setup_ease": 5.0,
      "best_for": [
        "Software developers",
        "Engineering teams"
      ],
      "risk_categories": [],
      "search_text": "opencsgs/csghub opencsgs open_source other bronze conditional watch software developers engineering teams hugging face",
      "material_mover": false
    },
    {
      "id": "evt_6874ea002ca3bd79a16e",
      "entity_id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "item_url": "/item/opencsgs-csghub/",
      "title": "opencsgs/csghub",
      "category": "other",
      "kind": "stars_changed",
      "occurred_at": "2026-10-09T05:11:59.425720Z",
      "before": 4060,
      "after": 4059,
      "explanation": "Stars changed: 4060 → 4059.",
      "explanation_scope": "catalog_snapshot_delta",
      "evidence_refs": {},
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "score": 5.2,
      "entity_kind": "open_source",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "type": "Dataset",
      "section": "Research",
      "local_ai": false,
      "local_model_compatible": false,
      "discovery_topic": "research",
      "discovery_topic_status": "unreviewed",
      "setup_ease": 5.0,
      "best_for": [
        "Software developers",
        "Engineering teams"
      ],
      "risk_categories": [],
      "search_text": "opencsgs/csghub opencsgs open_source other bronze conditional watch software developers engineering teams hugging face",
      "material_mover": false
    },
    {
      "id": "evt_9f424e37e15a72544a99",
      "entity_id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "item_url": "/item/opencsgs-csghub/",
      "title": "opencsgs/csghub",
      "category": "other",
      "kind": "stars_changed",
      "occurred_at": "2026-10-08T05:15:53.503430Z",
      "before": 4059,
      "after": 4060,
      "explanation": "Stars changed: 4059 → 4060.",
      "explanation_scope": "catalog_snapshot_delta",
      "evidence_refs": {},
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "score": 5.2,
      "entity_kind": "open_source",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "type": "Dataset",
      "section": "Research",
      "local_ai": false,
      "local_model_compatible": false,
      "discovery_topic": "research",
      "discovery_topic_status": "unreviewed",
      "setup_ease": 5.0,
      "best_for": [
        "Software developers",
        "Engineering teams"
      ],
      "risk_categories": [],
      "search_text": "opencsgs/csghub opencsgs open_source other bronze conditional watch software developers engineering teams hugging face",
      "material_mover": false
    },
    {
      "id": "evt_82210dd087b5d4b2dc86",
      "entity_id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "item_url": "/item/opencsgs-csghub/",
      "title": "opencsgs/csghub",
      "category": "other",
      "kind": "stars_changed",
      "occurred_at": "2026-10-06T11:51:05.323120Z",
      "before": 4057,
      "after": 4059,
      "explanation": "Stars changed: 4057 → 4059.",
      "explanation_scope": "catalog_snapshot_delta",
      "evidence_refs": {},
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "score": 5.2,
      "entity_kind": "open_source",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "type": "Dataset",
      "section": "Research",
      "local_ai": false,
      "local_model_compatible": false,
      "discovery_topic": "research",
      "discovery_topic_status": "unreviewed",
      "setup_ease": 5.0,
      "best_for": [
        "Software developers",
        "Engineering teams"
      ],
      "risk_categories": [],
      "search_text": "opencsgs/csghub opencsgs open_source other bronze conditional watch software developers engineering teams hugging face",
      "material_mover": false
    },
    {
      "id": "evt_b5771b78f55795452171",
      "entity_id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "item_url": "/item/opencsgs-csghub/",
      "title": "opencsgs/csghub",
      "category": "other",
      "kind": "stars_changed",
      "occurred_at": "2026-10-05T17:12:19.837870Z",
      "before": 4059,
      "after": 4057,
      "explanation": "Stars changed: 4059 → 4057.",
      "explanation_scope": "catalog_snapshot_delta",
      "evidence_refs": {},
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "score": 5.2,
      "entity_kind": "open_source",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "type": "Dataset",
      "section": "Research",
      "local_ai": false,
      "local_model_compatible": false,
      "discovery_topic": "research",
      "discovery_topic_status": "unreviewed",
      "setup_ease": 5.0,
      "best_for": [
        "Software developers",
        "Engineering teams"
      ],
      "risk_categories": [],
      "search_text": "opencsgs/csghub opencsgs open_source other bronze conditional watch software developers engineering teams hugging face",
      "material_mover": false
    },
    {
      "id": "evt_209bf882bcaa9ef0a6fd",
      "entity_id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "item_url": "/item/opencsgs-csghub/",
      "title": "opencsgs/csghub",
      "category": "other",
      "kind": "stars_changed",
      "occurred_at": "2026-10-01T17:20:20.713752Z",
      "before": 4118,
      "after": 4059,
      "explanation": "Stars changed: 4118 → 4059.",
      "explanation_scope": "catalog_snapshot_delta",
      "evidence_refs": {},
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "score": 5.2,
      "entity_kind": "open_source",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "type": "Dataset",
      "section": "Research",
      "local_ai": false,
      "local_model_compatible": false,
      "discovery_topic": "research",
      "discovery_topic_status": "unreviewed",
      "setup_ease": 5.0,
      "best_for": [
        "Software developers",
        "Engineering teams"
      ],
      "risk_categories": [],
      "search_text": "opencsgs/csghub opencsgs open_source other bronze conditional watch software developers engineering teams hugging face",
      "material_mover": false
    },
    {
      "id": "evt_71be5e17e5ca07e71555",
      "entity_id": "gh:opencsgs/csghub",
      "item_url": "/item/opencsgs-csghub/",
      "title": "opencsgs/csghub",
      "category": "other",
      "kind": "stars_changed",
      "occurred_at": "2026-09-30T05:08:12.323055Z",
      "before": 4116,
      "after": 4118,
      "explanation": "Stars changed: 4116 → 4118.",
      "explanation_scope": "catalog_snapshot_delta",
      "evidence_refs": {},
      "tier": "Bronze",
      "risk": "conditional",
      "verdict": "watch",
      "score": 5.2,
      "entity_kind": "open_source",
      "verification_stage": "discovered",
      "type": "Dataset",
      "section": "Research",
      "local_ai": false,
      "local_model_compatible": false,
      "discovery_topic": "research",
      "discovery_topic_status": "unreviewed",
      "setup_ease": 5.0,
      "best_for": [
        "Software developers",
        "Engineering teams"
      ],
      "risk_categories": [],
      "search_text": "opencsgs/csghub opencsgs open_source other bronze conditional watch software developers engineering teams hugging face",
      "material_mover": false
    }
  ]
}